NewsWomen in Biz

This month we celebrated National Women’s Day and honor the incredible strength and vision of women leaders, especially those at the helm of mission-driven nonprofit organizations.  It is a moment to recognize the profound societal contributions of a sector where women are the driving force, but also to confront the persistent “broken ladders” that impede their path to the top.  The nonprofit sector, which is vital to American society, is largely a female-dominated workforce, with women making up approximately 75% of its employees. Yet, this majority representation sharply diminishes as the organizational budget size increases, illustrating a significant leadership gap.

At Catalyst, we conduct executive searches that have a diverse candidate pool and many of the CEOs selected to lead are women. So, what is the current data behind the disparities that still exist that requires Board education and allow the organization to forge a path of equity and set an example for the nonprofit’s workplace as a whole? We thought we would share some thoughts for your leadership to consider to not only secure top talent in a female led sector, but also re-frame the overall approach to equity within the nonprofit organization.

The Data Behind the Disparity

While women are well-represented in leadership at smaller organizations, the disparity is stark at the largest nonprofits:

  • Small vs. Large Organizations: Women hold 56% of chief executive roles at nonprofits with annual budgets under $1 million. However, this figure plummets to just 22% of chief executives at the largest 2,200 nonprofits with annual budgets of $50 million or more.
  • The Pay Gap: This underrepresentation is compounded by a persistent pay gap. Female CEOs at the largest nonprofits face a median pay gap of 18% compared to their male counterparts. In fiscal year 2022, women represented less than one-third of CEOs at organizations with budgets over $50 million, and they earned only 77 cents for every dollar male CEOs earned.

The challenges intensify at the intersection of race and gender, as women of color in the nonprofit sector often encounter additional barriers, including the chronic underfunding of the organizations they lead.

Forging a Path to Equity

Closing this gap requires a multi-pronged approach to dismantle systemic barriers and ensure gender equity is a core value, not a side project. Recommendations for achieving parity include:

  • Systemic Change: Advocating for the passage of paid leave and equal pay laws.
  • Workplace Evolution: Encouraging employers to promote mentorship and sponsorship opportunities for women and to establish transparent, equitable performance management and promotion processes.
  • Cultural Audit: Nonprofits must ask critical questions about their culture, from analyzing gender, racial, and other pay gaps to ensuring diverse input in hiring and leadership composition.

As we honor the women who are actively leading change and serving their communities this month (and everyday). These are the CEOs and Executive Directors who dedicate their careers to building homes, strengthening communities, and empowering others—from the leaders of massive international organizations to those running vital local centers for women and development consulting services. Their mission is clear: to not only advance the cause of their organizations but to ensure that the nonprofit sector finally reflects the equity and opportunity it champions for the world. Therefore, it is worth taking the time to pre-plan prior to launching an executive search to ensure equity for women, and men, in leadership positions.

Michelle Turman, MA, CFRE is the CEO of Catalyst Consulting Services whose mission is to facilitate positive change for nonprofits in the areas of executive searches, organizational management, and fundraising. With over thirty years of nonprofit experience, Turman has been responsible for increasing the impact and best practices of nonprofit organizations she serves and has raised over $165 million for the Tampa Bay community through her professional and personal philanthropic efforts.

 Catalyst Consulting Services | 813-839-2282 | www.catalystcs.org